Peer Review Process

PREDIKAT: Journal of Community Service uses double-blind peer review: authors and reviewers do not know each other's identities.

Workflow

  1. Initial screening (≤ 14 days) by the Managing Editor: scope, completeness, use of the template, and a similarity check. Outcome: sent to review, returned for formatting, or desk-rejected.
  2. Reviewer assignment: the Section Editor invites at least two reviewers with expertise in the topic and from institutions other than the authors'.
  3. Review (2–3 weeks) using the journal's review form: originality and novelty, soundness of method, validity of results, quality of discussion, currency of references, and clarity of language.
  4. Editorial decision based on reviewer recommendations: Accept, Minor revision, Major revision, Resubmit for review, or Decline. Where recommendations conflict, the editor invites a third reviewer.
  5. Revision by the authors: up to 2 weeks (minor) or 4 weeks (major), with a response table. Major revisions are reviewed again.
  6. Copyediting (language and style), layout, author proofreading, then publication with a DOI.

Timing

First decision on average ≤ 6 weeks after screening. Review-time statistics and acceptance rates are reported on this page every year.

Confidentiality and responsibility

Reviewers must not share, cite, or use a manuscript's content, and must declare any conflict of interest. Manuscripts written by board members are handled by another editor through the same process. Objections to a decision can be raised through Complaints and Appeals.